Do Miracles Happen? Can a Modern Person Believe in Them?
The Short Answer
The Catholic Church holds that miracles really happen. A miracle is an event that God brings about beyond the ordinary course of nature, as a sign. If God exists and made nature, there is nothing irrational about His acting within it; the question is only whether He has done so in a given case, and that is a matter of evidence. The Church is cautious about particular claims, and investigates them strictly. But she holds that the miracles of Christ, above all His Resurrection, are real, and that miracles continue to be one of the signs that make faith reasonable (CCC 156).
Many people today think that belief in miracles belongs to a pre-scientific age. The philosopher David Hume gave this view its classic form in the eighteenth century, and it is worth taking seriously.
What the Church Does and Does Not Claim
The Church does not claim:
- That every unusual event is a miracle. Most remarkable recoveries and strange coincidences have natural explanations, and the Church is often more sceptical than the people who report them.
- That Catholics must believe in any particular modern miracle. Approved miracles, at Lourdes or in a canonisation, are judged worthy of belief, but they are not part of the deposit of faith.
- That miracles break the laws of nature like a vandal. God is the author of nature. A miracle is not God contradicting Himself, but God acting directly where He usually acts through natural causes.
- That miracles force anyone to believe. Jesus Himself “could do no mighty work” in Nazareth, “and he marveled because of their unbelief” (Mark 6:5–6).
The Church does claim that “the miracles of Christ and the saints, prophecies, the Church’s growth and holiness, and her fruitfulness and stability” are “the most certain signs of divine Revelation, adapted to the intelligence of all” (CCC 156).
Why Catholics Believe It
If God exists, miracles are possible
St Thomas Aquinas defined miracles as things “done by divine agency beyond the order commonly observed in nature” (Summa contra Gentiles III). The definition matters. Nature has a regular order because God gave it one. But the One who established that order is not its prisoner. If a novelist can write a new turn into the story, the Creator can act within the world He made.
So the real question is not whether miracles are possible, but whether God exists. If He does not, miracles are impossible by definition. If He does, they are possible, and each claim must be examined on its merits. (See Does God Exist?)
The miracles of Jesus are part of the historical record
Jesus’ contemporaries did not deny that He performed remarkable deeds. His opponents attributed them to the devil (Mark 3:22). St Peter could say to a crowd in Jerusalem, a few weeks after the Crucifixion, that Jesus was “attested to you by God with mighty works and wonders and signs which God did through him in your midst, as you yourselves know” (Acts 2:22). Jesus pointed to His works as evidence: “even though you do not believe me, believe the works, that you may know and understand that the Father is in me and I am in the Father” (John 10:38).
The greatest of these is the Resurrection, which can be examined by ordinary historical methods. (See Did Jesus Really Rise From the Dead?)
Miracles are signs, not stunts
In the Gospels, Jesus’ miracles are never displays to impress. He refused to perform signs on demand: “An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a sign” (Matthew 12:39). His healings show who He is and what His Kingdom means: “the blind receive their sight and the lame walk, lepers are cleansed and the deaf hear, and the dead are raised up, and the poor have good news preached to them” (Matthew 11:5). The Catechism calls them signs that “invite belief in him” (CCC 548). That is why the Church looks not only at whether an event is unexplained, but at its meaning and its fruits.
The Church investigates miracles strictly
The Church does not take miracle claims on trust. At Lourdes, alleged cures are examined by the Lourdes Medical Bureau and then by an international committee of doctors, believers and non-believers among them. The cure must be of a serious, diagnosed illness; it must be sudden, complete and lasting; and it must have no medical explanation. Thousands of cures have been reported since 1858. As of 2025, the Church had recognised 72 as miracles.
In the causes of saints, a proposed miracle, usually a healing, is examined by a board of medical experts before theologians and cardinals consider it. Normally one recognised miracle is required for beatification and another for canonisation. Many proposed miracles are rejected.
Common Objections
”Science has shown that miracles are impossible.”
Science studies the regular order of nature. It can tell us that, left to themselves, dead bodies do not rise. But a miracle is precisely not nature left to itself; it is a claim that God has acted. Science cannot show that God never acts, any more than studying how a game is usually played proves that the referee never intervenes. That is a philosophical belief, not a scientific finding.
”Hume showed that the evidence against a miracle is always greater.”
Hume argued that “a miracle is a violation of the laws of nature; and as a firm and unalterable experience has established these laws, the proof against a miracle, from the very nature of the fact, is as entire as any argument from experience can possibly be imagined” (Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, X). But this assumes what it sets out to prove. If experience against miracles is “unalterable,” that is because every reported miracle has already been ruled out. And by Hume’s reasoning, no evidence could ever establish a truly unprecedented event, which would make some genuine discoveries impossible to accept.
”People in the ancient world were credulous. They saw miracles everywhere.”
Ancient people knew perfectly well that virgins do not conceive and the dead do not rise. That is why such claims were astonishing. When Joseph learned Mary was with child, his first thought was to divorce her quietly (Matthew 1:19). When the women reported the empty tomb, the apostles thought it “an idle tale” (Luke 24:11).
”If God can work miracles, why doesn’t He heal everyone?”
A miracle is a sign, not a replacement for the ordinary order of nature that God also wills. If God healed every illness at once, the world would no longer have a stable order at all. The miracles of Christ were signs of the Kingdom to come, when God “will wipe away every tear” (Revelation 21:4). They are a foretaste, not yet the fulfilment. (See Why Does God Allow Suffering?)
In Summary
A miracle is an act of God beyond the ordinary course of nature, given as a sign. If God exists, miracles are possible, and each claim is a question of evidence. The miracles of Jesus are part of the historical record, and His Resurrection is the greatest of them. The Church investigates modern claims with care, and accepts only a small fraction. Science studies the order God gave the world; it cannot show that He never acts within it. Belief in miracles is not credulity. It is what follows from taking seriously the possibility that the world has a Creator who cares about it.
See also Is Faith Irrational? and Isn’t Science the Only Real Path to Truth?
This article follows the method St Robert Bellarmine used in his Controversies*: state the question fairly, clear away misunderstandings, make the case, then answer each objection. Bellarmine counted the glory of miracles among his marks of the true Church in* De Ecclesia militante*. See How We Answer Objections.*
Sources
- Scripture: Revised Standard Version, Second Catholic Edition (Ignatius Press). Matthew 1:19, 11:4–5, 12:39; Mark 3:22, 6:5–6; Luke 24:11; John 10:37–38, 20:30–31; Acts 2:22; Revelation 21:4.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 156, 547–550. vatican.va
- First Vatican Council, Dei Filius (1870), ch. 3.
- St Thomas Aquinas, Summa contra Gentiles III, chs. 98–103. Quoted in Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, “Miracles.” stanford.edu
- David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748), section X, “Of Miracles.”
- “Lourdes announces 72nd miracle,” Catholic World Report, 16 April 2025. catholicworldreport.com
- St Robert Bellarmine, De Controversiis: De Ecclesia militante, Book IV (the notes of the Church).