✝ Catholic Treasury Network
Apologetics · Jesus

Did Jesus Really Rise From the Dead?

The Short Answer

Christians believe that Jesus, crucified and buried, rose bodily from the dead on the third day. This is not a symbol or a feeling but a claim about history, and it can be examined. A small set of facts is accepted by most scholars, believers and sceptics alike: Jesus died by crucifixion; His followers soon afterwards sincerely believed they had seen Him alive; their lives were transformed; former sceptics such as James and Paul became believers; and, most scholars think, His tomb was found empty. No natural explanation accounts for all of these. The Resurrection does.

St Paul did not hedge: “If Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile and you are still in your sins” (1 Corinthians 15:17). Many people today assume that a resurrection is simply impossible, or that the story grew up as a legend. Those are serious objections, and the evidence should be weighed.

What the Church Does and Does Not Claim

The Church does not claim:

The Church does claim that “the mystery of Christ’s resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified, as the New Testament bears witness” (CCC 639), and that “it is impossible not to acknowledge it as an historical fact” (CCC 643).

Why Catholics Believe It

The scholar Gary Habermas surveyed a vast body of academic writing on the Resurrection, by believers and sceptics, and identified a handful of facts that most scholars accept, whatever they think about the Resurrection itself. They are sometimes called the “minimal facts.”

1. Jesus died by crucifixion

Jesus’ death by Roman crucifixion is one of the best-attested facts of ancient history: it is recorded in all four Gospels, in Paul, and by Tacitus and Josephus. Roman soldiers were practised executioners.

2. His followers believed they saw Him risen

The earliest evidence is a summary of the faith that Paul says he “received” and handed on: that Christ died, was buried, was raised on the third day, and appeared to Peter, then to the Twelve, then “to more than five hundred brethren at one time, most of whom are still alive,” then to James, then to all the apostles, and last of all to Paul himself (1 Corinthians 15:3–8). Many scholars, including sceptical ones, date this creed to within a few years of the Crucifixion. Paul’s point about the five hundred is plain: ask them.

3. Their lives were transformed

The disciples fled when Jesus was arrested, and Peter denied Him three times. Within weeks they were proclaiming His Resurrection in Jerusalem, the city where He had been executed, in the face of prison, beatings and death. People will die for something they believe is true. It is very hard to explain them dying for something they knew they had made up.

4. Sceptics were converted

James, a brother of the Lord, did not believe during Jesus’ ministry: “For even his brethren did not believe in him” (John 7:5). Yet he became a leader of the church in Jerusalem and was executed in 62, an event the Jewish historian Josephus records. Paul tells us the risen Jesus appeared to James. Paul himself had persecuted “the Church of God” (1 Corinthians 15:9) until, he said, the risen Christ appeared to him too.

5. The tomb was empty

Most scholars, though not all, also accept that the tomb was found empty. The Catechism calls the empty tomb “the first element we encounter in the framework of the Easter events” (CCC 640). Three points support it:

Common Objections

”Jesus didn’t really die. He fainted and revived.”

The swoon theory has been abandoned by serious scholars. Roman crucifixion was brutally effective, and a half-dead man staggering from a tomb would have convinced no one that he had conquered death.

”The disciples stole the body and lied.”

Then they suffered and died for what they knew was a lie, and the theory still cannot explain why James and Paul, who were not part of any plot, became believers.

”They had hallucinations, out of grief.”

Hallucinations are private experiences. They do not happen in the same way to groups, let alone to five hundred people, and they do not empty a tomb. Nor would grief explain the conversion of Paul, who was not grieving Jesus but persecuting His followers.

”The story grew into a legend over time.”

The creed in 1 Corinthians 15 dates to within a few years of the events, while eyewitnesses were alive and could contradict it. That is far too soon for a legend to replace the facts.

”Dead people don’t rise. Miracles are impossible.”

If there is no God, that is true. But if God exists, a resurrection is not impossible, and the question becomes whether the evidence points to one. The Anglican scholar N. T. Wright argued in The Resurrection of the Son of God (2003) that the rise of early Christianity, with its new and specific belief in the bodily resurrection of one man before the end of history, cannot be explained without both an empty tomb and real meetings with the risen Jesus, and that these are best explained by the Resurrection itself. (See Does God Exist?)

In Summary

Most historians accept that Jesus died by crucifixion, that His followers soon sincerely believed they had met Him alive, that their lives and the lives of former sceptics were transformed, and that the tomb was found empty. Fraud, fainting, hallucination and legend each fail to explain all of this. The Resurrection explains it all. If it happened, Jesus is who He claimed to be, death has been overcome, and those who belong to Him will rise too. That is why Christians have greeted each other on Easter morning for two thousand years: “Christ is risen! He is risen indeed!”

See also Did Jesus Claim to Be God? and What Does the Resurrection Mean for Us?

This article follows the method St Robert Bellarmine used in his Controversies*: state the question fairly, clear away misunderstandings, make the case, then answer each objection. See How We Answer Objections.*

Sources