✝ Catholic Treasury Network
Apologetics · Church History

What Really Happened in the Inquisition?

The Short Answer

There was not one Inquisition but several: medieval tribunals against heresy, and later the Spanish, Portuguese and Roman inquisitions. They used coercion, torture and, in some cases, execution against people for their beliefs, and the Church has asked forgiveness for this. But the popular picture of millions burned is a myth. Historians working from the inquisitions’ own archives estimate that the Spanish Inquisition, the most notorious, executed a few thousand people over three and a half centuries, and that most people who came before the tribunals were given penances or acquitted. The truth is troubling enough without exaggeration.

The Inquisition is often presented as proof that the Catholic Church is inherently oppressive. Honest history requires telling the truth on both sides: what was really done, and what has been added by legend.

What the Church Does and Does Not Claim

The Church does not claim:

The Church does claim that “truth cannot impose itself except by virtue of its own truth,” and that no one may be forced to act against conscience in religious matters (Dignitatis Humanae 1–2).

What the Inquisitions Were

The medieval inquisition began in the late twelfth and thirteenth centuries, mainly in southern France and northern Italy, in response to the Cathar movement. Popes appointed inquisitors, often Dominican or Franciscan friars, to investigate heresy.

The Spanish Inquisition was established in 1478 at the request of Ferdinand and Isabella. Authorised by the Pope but controlled by the Spanish crown, it targeted first converts from Judaism suspected of secretly practising their former faith, later converts from Islam, Protestants and others. It was finally abolished in 1834.

The Portuguese Inquisition was established in 1536, also under royal control.

The Roman Inquisition, established by Pope Paul III in 1542, dealt mainly with Protestantism in Italy and with doctrine. It tried Galileo, and it later developed into today’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Why did they exist?

In medieval and early modern Europe, Church and state were deeply intertwined, and religious unity was seen as the foundation of social order. Heresy was treated as a crime against society, something like treason, and secular rulers and mobs often punished it violently. The inquisitions were partly an attempt to bring legal procedure to this: they required evidence, heard testimony and kept careful records. Many historians judge them to have been less arbitrary than many secular courts of the time. That does not make them just.

How many died?

Claims of millions, even nine million, victims have no basis in the evidence. For the Spanish Inquisition, historians generally estimate several thousand executions over 350 years, most in its first decades. In 1998 the Vatican opened the archives of the Roman Inquisition to scholars and held an international symposium of historians; its proceedings, published in 2004, reported that the Spanish Inquisition tried about 125,000 people, of whom only a small percentage were executed. The Roman Inquisition executed far fewer.

Torture and execution

The inquisitions used torture to obtain confessions, as did virtually every court in Europe, religious and secular. Their rules generally limited it, and required confessions to be confirmed afterwards without torture. None of this makes torture acceptable; the Church today teaches that it is gravely contrary to human dignity (CCC 2297–2298). Inquisitors did not carry out executions themselves; those condemned were handed over to the secular authorities, usually to be burned. That legal fiction did not remove the Church’s responsibility.

Common Objections

”The Inquisition burned millions of witches.”

Most European witch trials took place in secular and Protestant courts, especially in Germany, Switzerland and Scotland. The Spanish Inquisition was notably sceptical of witchcraft accusations. After investigating a witch panic in the Basque country in the early seventeenth century, the inquisitor Alonso de Salazar Frías concluded there was no real evidence, and the Inquisition largely stopped executing people for witchcraft.

”Everyone knows how cruel the Spanish Inquisition was.”

Much of what “everyone knows” comes from what historians call the Black Legend: anti-Spanish and anti-Catholic propaganda produced in Protestant countries during the wars of religion. Lurid accounts were printed for political purposes, and some myths have proved remarkably durable. The real record is bad enough without them.

”The Church has never admitted any of this.”

She has. On 12 March 2000, during the Great Jubilee, St John Paul II led a Day of Pardon in St Peter’s Basilica, asking forgiveness for sins committed by members of the Church, including “the violence some have used in the service of the truth.” The Second Vatican Council had already taught that faith can never be forced (Dignitatis Humanae).

In Summary

The inquisitions were real wrongs committed by Christians in the name of the faith: coercion, torture and executions for belief. The Church does not defend them, and has asked forgiveness for them. But they deserve to be remembered accurately. The numbers were far lower than the legend claims, the witch hunts were mostly not the Inquisition’s work, and much of the popular image comes from wartime propaganda. The truth is enough; it does not need to be exaggerated.

See also Didn’t the Church Persecute Galileo for Science? and Weren’t the Crusades Just Wars of Conquest?

This article follows the method St Robert Bellarmine used in his Controversies*: state the question fairly, clear away misunderstandings, make the case, then answer each objection. See How We Answer Objections.*

Sources