Isn't Purgatory Unbiblical? Answering the Objections
The Short Answer
Purgatory is the Catholic name for the final purification of those who die in God’s friendship but are not yet completely holy. It adds nothing to Christ’s sacrifice; it is that sacrifice completing its work in us. The word is not in the Bible, but the reality is: prayer for the dead, a believer saved “only as through fire,” and the promise that nothing unclean will enter heaven. And Christians were praying for their dead long before the Middle Ages.
A Frequent Target
Few Catholic doctrines draw as much criticism from other Christians as purgatory. For many Protestants it represents everything they rejected at the Reformation: unbiblical tradition, salvation by works, and the sale of indulgences.
The Catholic Church teaches that those who die in God’s grace but are not yet fully purified undergo a final purification before entering heaven, and that the prayers of the living can help them (CCC 1030–1032). (For a full explanation of the doctrine, see What Is Purgatory?)
What the Church Does and Does Not Claim
The Church does not claim:
- That purgatory is a second chance. It is only for those who die in God’s grace. It is not a way out of hell, and no one in purgatory is in danger of being lost.
- That it adds to Christ’s sacrifice. All purification comes from Christ’s merits.
- That it is a place on a map, or measured in earthly time. The Church has defined that the purification exists and that our prayers help; she has not defined its details.
- That everyone goes there. Someone who dies perfectly purified goes straight to heaven.
- That indulgences can be bought. The sale of indulgences was an abuse, and the Church forbade it.
The Church does claim that “all who die in God’s grace and friendship, but still imperfectly purified, are indeed assured of their eternal salvation; but after death they undergo purification, so as to achieve the holiness necessary to enter the joy of heaven” (CCC 1030).
Objection 1: “Purgatory Is Not in the Bible”
It is true that the word “purgatory” does not appear in the Bible. Neither does the word “Trinity,” or “Incarnation.” The question is whether the reality is there.
Catholics point to several passages:
Prayer for the dead. In 2 Maccabees 12:39–45, Judas Maccabeus has prayers and a sacrifice offered for fallen soldiers. The text praises this as “a holy and pious thought,” and says: “Therefore he made atonement for the dead, that they might be delivered from their sin” (12:45). Prayer for the dead makes sense only if the dead can be helped, which rules out both heaven (no help needed) and hell (no help possible).
Protestants respond that 2 Maccabees is not in their Bible. But even if one does not accept it as Scripture, it is undeniable historical evidence that Jews prayed for the dead before Christ. Jesus and the apostles never condemned the practice, and Jews still pray for their dead today, in prayers such as the El Malei Rachamim and the Yizkor memorial service.
Saved “as through fire.” St Paul writes that on the Day of judgement, each person’s work will be tested by fire: “If any man’s work is burned up, he will suffer loss, though he himself will be saved, but only as through fire” (1 Corinthians 3:15). Here is a person who is saved, yet suffers loss and passes through fire. This is not heaven, where there is no loss, nor hell, where there is no salvation.
Forgiveness in the age to come. Jesus says that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, “either in this age or in the age to come” (Matthew 12:32). This implies that some sins can be forgiven in the age to come.
Paying the last penny. Jesus warns that someone who does not settle with his accuser will be thrown into prison: “you will never get out till you have paid the last penny” (Matthew 5:26). Many early Christians read this as a reference to purification after death.
Nothing unclean. Revelation says of the heavenly city: “But nothing unclean shall enter it” (Revelation 21:27). Yet most Christians die with some imperfections. Something must happen between death and heaven.
Objection 2: “Purgatory Denies That Christ’s Sacrifice Was Enough”
This is the most serious objection. If Christ paid for all our sins on the Cross, how can there be any further purification?
Catholics agree completely that Christ’s sacrifice is sufficient. Purgatory does not add anything to it. Everything in purgatory is the application of Christ’s merits, not a supplement to them.
The issue is not whether Christ’s sacrifice is enough, but whether we are yet fully transformed by it. Every Christian, Protestant or Catholic, believes that after conversion a believer must still grow in holiness. Protestants call this sanctification. Most believers do not reach perfect holiness in this life. Yet we will be perfectly holy in heaven. So at some point, God completes the work.
Many Protestants believe this happens instantly at death. Catholics believe it is a process of purification. But both agree that God finishes the job. Purgatory is the Catholic name for the completion of sanctification.
Objection 3: “The Thief on the Cross Went Straight to Paradise”
Jesus told the penitent thief, “Truly, I say to you, today you will be with me in Paradise” (Luke 23:43). Doesn’t that rule out purgatory?
Not necessarily. Catholics do not teach that everyone goes to purgatory. The thief’s dying repentance, his public confession of Christ and his suffering beside Him could well have purified him completely. Some interpreters also note that “Paradise” in Jewish thought could refer to the abode of the righteous dead before Christ opened heaven.
Objection 4: “To Be Absent From the Body Is to Be Present With the Lord”
St Paul writes that “we would rather be away from the body and at home with the Lord” (2 Corinthians 5:8). Protestants often take this to mean that believers go straight to God.
But Paul does not say “immediately.” He expresses his desire to be with Christ, which Catholics share. Purgatory is not a place far from Christ. Pope Benedict XVI wrote that “some recent theologians are of the opinion that the fire which both burns and saves is Christ himself, the Judge and Saviour,” and that “the encounter with him is the decisive act of judgement” (Spe Salvi 47).
Objection 5: “It Was Invented in the Middle Ages to Make Money”
The abuses of indulgence-selling before the Reformation were real, and the Council of Trent condemned them. But the belief that the dead can be helped by prayer is far older.
- The inscription of Abercius, a bishop of the late second century, asks: “let him pray for Abercius.”
- Tertullian, around 211, wrote: “As often as the anniversary comes round, we make offerings for the dead as birthday honours” (The Chaplet 3).
- St Perpetua, martyred in 203, prayed for her dead brother Dinocrates and saw a vision of his relief (Passion of Perpetua and Felicity 7–8).
- St Augustine recorded the dying words of his mother, St Monica, in 387: “Lay this body anywhere, let not the care for it trouble you at all,” but “remember me at the Lord’s altar, wherever you be” (Confessions IX.11.27).
- Ancient Christian liturgies, East and West, include prayers for the dead.
The Orthodox Churches, which split from Rome centuries before the Reformation, also pray for the dead, though they describe the intermediate state differently.
Even C. S. Lewis
The Anglican writer C. S. Lewis believed in purgatory. In Letters to Malcolm (1964) he wrote: “I believe in Purgatory,” and “Our souls demand Purgatory, don’t they?” He imagined a soul at heaven’s door, conscious of its own unworthiness, saying: “With submission, sir, and if there is no objection, I’d rather be cleaned first” (ch. 20).
The Heart of It
Purgatory is not a rival to Christ’s sacrifice, nor a punishment invented by the Church. It is the mercy of a God who will not leave His work unfinished, and who makes us fit to see Him face to face.
See also What Is Purgatory Like? and How Do Catholics Pray for Someone Who Has Died?
This article follows the method St Robert Bellarmine used in his Controversies*: state the question fairly, clear away misunderstandings, make the case, then answer each objection. Bellarmine wrote a full treatise,* De Purgatorio (On Purgatory), working through these same passages. See How We Answer Objections.
Sources
- Scripture: Revised Standard Version, Second Catholic Edition (Ignatius Press). 2 Maccabees 12:39–45; Matthew 5:26, 12:32; Luke 23:43; 1 Corinthians 3:15; 2 Corinthians 5:8; Revelation 21:27.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, nn. 1030–1032.
- Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi (2007), 47. catholicculture.org
- Inscription of Abercius (late second century). wikipedia.org
- Tertullian, The Chaplet 3. Tr. S. Thelwall, Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3. bkv.unifr.ch
- Passion of Perpetua and Felicity 7–8. Ante-Nicene Fathers, vol. 3.
- St Augustine, Confessions IX.11.27. Tr. J. G. Pilkington, Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, 1st series, vol. 1. bkv.unifr.ch
- C. S. Lewis, Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer (1964), ch. 20.
- St Robert Bellarmine, De Controversiis: De Purgatorio.