✝ Catholic Treasury Network
Apologetics · Other Faiths

What Is the Difference Between Catholics and Orthodox?

The Short Answer

Catholics and Orthodox share more than any other two Christian traditions: the same seven sacraments, bishops in apostolic succession, the first seven ecumenical councils, Sacred Tradition, and deep devotion to Mary and the saints. The Catholic Church recognises Orthodox sacraments as valid. The central difference is the authority of the Pope. Catholics believe the Bishop of Rome, as successor of St Peter, has primacy over the whole Church; the Orthodox accept a primacy of honour but not of universal jurisdiction. Most other differences flow from that, or are matters of custom.

They have been separated since the Great Schism, traditionally dated to 1054. The Catholic Church has about 1.4 billion members; the Orthodox Churches together have more than 200 million. (For the history, see What Caused the Great Schism of 1054?)

What the Church Does and Does Not Claim

The Church does not claim:

The Church does claim that with the Orthodox Churches the communion is “so profound that it lacks little to attain the fullness that would permit a common celebration of the Lord’s Eucharist” (CCC 838, quoting St Paul VI).

What They Share

What Is the Orthodox Church?

The Orthodox Church is a communion of self-governing (autocephalous) Churches, such as the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople and the Churches of Greece, Russia, Serbia, Romania, Bulgaria, Antioch and others, sharing the same faith and sacraments. The Ecumenical Patriarch is honoured as “first among equals,” but has no authority over the other Churches.

Where They Differ

The Pope

This is the central issue. Catholics believe that the Bishop of Rome has a primacy of authority over the whole Church, and that when he solemnly defines a doctrine of faith or morals he is protected from error. (See Where Is the Papacy in the Bible?) The Orthodox generally accept that Rome had a primacy of honour in the early Church, but reject universal papal jurisdiction and infallibility as later developments, holding that the highest authority lies in ecumenical councils. St John Paul II, in Ut Unum Sint (1995), invited other Christians to help find a way of exercising the papal primacy that all could accept.

The Filioque

Latin Catholics say in the Creed that the Holy Spirit proceeds “from the Father and the Son”; the Orthodox say “from the Father.” Many theologians on both sides now see this as largely a difference of emphasis, but it remains under discussion. (See What Is the Filioque?)

Purgatory and the Immaculate Conception

Both pray for the dead, but the Orthodox avoid the Western term “purgatory” and its language of punishment and satisfaction. They honour Mary as all-holy, but do not accept the 1854 dogma of the Immaculate Conception, partly because they understand original sin differently and partly because it was defined by a pope alone. Most Orthodox do believe in Mary’s bodily assumption, celebrated as the Dormition.

Divorce and remarriage

The Catholic Church holds that a valid sacramental marriage cannot be dissolved. The Orthodox Church also sees marriage as lifelong, but in some circumstances, out of pastoral mercy (oikonomia), allows a second or third marriage after divorce, with a penitential rite.

Customs

Other differences are matters of discipline, not doctrine: the Orthodox, like most Eastern Catholics, ordain married men as priests, though bishops are celibate; they use leavened bread; infants receive Communion at baptism; and many Orthodox Churches use the Julian calendar, so Easter often falls on a different date.

Common Objections

”If they’re so close, why can’t they share Communion?”

Because full communion, including agreement about the Church’s unity and authority, does not yet exist. Catholic law allows Orthodox Christians to receive Communion in a Catholic church if they ask of their own accord and are properly disposed, and permits Catholics to receive from Orthodox priests when they cannot reach a Catholic one (canon 844). The Orthodox Churches generally do not permit this.

”Isn’t the papacy just Roman power politics?”

Catholics believe the papacy has its roots in Christ’s words to Peter and in the early Church’s recognition of Rome’s special role, though it developed over time and has sometimes been exercised badly. The question is not whether popes have always been good, but what Christ intended for the unity of His Church. The Catholic Church has invited the Orthodox to help discern how that ministry can serve unity.

In Summary

Catholics and Orthodox share the faith of the first millennium, the sacraments and the priesthood. The heart of the division is the role of the Pope; other differences flow from it or are matters of custom. In 1965 Pope Paul VI and Patriarch Athenagoras lifted the mutual excommunications of 1054, and since then popes and patriarchs have met and prayed together many times. For Catholics, the Orthodox are not strangers but brothers and sisters. St John Paul II often said the Church must learn to breathe again with both her lungs, East and West, and Christ prayed “that they may all be one” (John 17:21).

See also What Caused the Great Schism of 1054?, What Are the Eastern Catholic Churches? and What Is the Difference Between Catholics and Protestants?

This article follows the method St Robert Bellarmine used in his Controversies*: state the question fairly, clear away misunderstandings, make the case, then answer each objection. See How We Answer Objections.*

Sources